Duong & Tran Intellectual Property

Vietnam

IP resources and filing guidance

Patentability requirements and protection term

Patent for industrial design: requires worldwide novelty, creativeness and industrial applicability.

  • Novelty: an industrial design shall be considered as novel if it significantly differs from other industrial designs that are already disclosed by way of use, written description or in any other forms inside or outside Vietnam prior to the filing date or the priority date (if the application has priority rights).

Grace period (exception to novelty)

An industrial design shall not be considered a loss of novelty if it was disclosed in the following cases:

  1. It is known to only a limited number of persons who are obliged to keep it secret.
  2. It is disclosed by the person entitled to file the industrial design application or by a person who obtained information about the industrial design directly or indirectly from the person entitled to file the industrial design application, provided that the industrial design application is filed in Vietnam within 06 months from the date of disclosure.
  3. It is published in the industrial property application or industrial property protection by an industrial property authority as a result of mistaken publication, or where the application is filed by a person ineligible to file it.
  • Creativeness: an industrial design shall be considered involving a creativeness if, based on an industrial design already publicly disclosed by use, written description or in any other forms inside or outside Vietnam prior to the filing date or the priority date (if the application has priority rights), it cannot be easily created by a person having ordinary skill in the art.
  • Industrial applicability: an industrial design shall be considered having industrial applicability if it can serve as a model for massive production of products having an external appearance or part thereof as the industrial design through manufacturing physical products by industrial or handicraft methods or for consistent reproduction of non-physical products in cyberspace.

The first protection term starts from granting date and ends five years from the filing date. A design patent is renewable for two consecutive five-year terms.

Restoration of a lapsed design patent: impossible.

International Conventions

Paris Convention, TRIPs, Hague Agreement Concerning the International Registration of Industrial Designs.

The deadline for filing an industrial design application claiming priority right is 06 months from the earliest priority date.

Examination system

Vietnam applies substantive examination system.

Non-patentable subject matters

  • Appearance of a product that is dictated by its technical features of the product;
  • Appearance of a civil or an industrial construction work, except for the appearance of the modules or separate sections that may be used independently or assembled to create a construction such as shops, kiosks, mobile homes or similar products;
  • Appearance of a product that is invisible during use of the product. Use of the product is understood as the exploitation of a product’s utility by ordinary methods and by any consumer, not including its maintenance or repair.

Minimum information sources to search for substantive examination

The minimum information sources that must be searched to identify industrial designs that are identical or similar to the industrial design in the application, for substantive examination of the application, include the following documents:

  • All industrial design applications received by the Intellectual Property Office of Vietnam(IP Vietnam) with publication dates earlier than the filing date or the priority date (if there is priority) of the application currently under examination;
  • Industrial design applications or industrial design patents published by other organizations or countries within 25 years before the filing date or the priority date of the application currently under examination (if that application claims priority) stored in the industrial design database of IP Vietnam;
  • Other information relating to industrial design collected and stored by IP Vietnam;
  • Industrial design applications received by IP Vietnam, international industrial design registration applications designating Vietnam, and having a filing date or priority date (if priority is claimed) earlier than or same filing date or priority date of the application under examination (for examination of the first-to-file principle).

IP Vietnam is obliged to carry out the search within the required resources above for substantive examination. However, it can also extend the search to any other sources it deems necessary for any disclosure describing the industrial design identical/similar to the industrial design in question.

Duty of Disclosure

Vietnam does not have regulations on “Duty of Disclosure”. Therefore, submission of prior art from the corresponding industrial design applications is not mandatory.

In practice, IP Vietnam has not requested submission of the documents/information for industrial design from foreign applications.

Unity of application/multiple industrial design application

A multiple industrial design application is acceptable in two cases: (i) some embodiments (variants) of design or (ii) designs of products in a set of products to be used together or to perform a general purpose.

  • There is no limit of the number of the embodiments in one application. However, embodiments filed in a single application must share a single general inventive concept and must not be significantly different from each other.
  • It is impossible to file a single application for designs for component part(s) of an integrated product and that integrated product with the same Locarno class as in some other countries.

Requirements on description

  • The description comprises: (i) similar designs (prior art designs (if any) (should specify there is or there is not prior art design(s)); (ii) list of drawings/photos; (iii) features of the design (describe the features of the industrial design in words).
  • The description is not published and not accompanied with design patent.

Requirements on drawings/photos

  • The drawings/photos must depict the industrial design in the same orientation and must be numbered consecutively in the following order: perspective (three-dimensional) view of the industrial design; front, rear, right, left, top, and bottom views of the industrial design. The six views must be taken at a right angle.
  • Broken lines are not accepted when they are intended for the parts that are unable to see in a specific view. Lines must be clean and sharp. The background colour of photos must be homogeneous and contrast with the color of the product embodying the industrial design.
  • The scales of views (except for perspective views) must be the same. Where the application is submitted in paper form, the image depicting the product embodying the industrial design must not exceed 190 mm x 277 mm and its largest dimension must not be smaller than 120 mm.
  • Drawings/photos representing partial designs must clearly distinguish the claimed portion and the unclaimed portion of the product by one of the following methods:
    • The claimed portion is represented by solid lines and the unclaimed portion by broken lines;
    • The claimed portion is represented in colors contrasting with the unclaimed portion.
  • There is no limitation on number of views.
  • In some specific cases, fewer views than 7 basis views are acceptable if they are sufficient to determine the design. For examples, if in a set of drawings/photos, a view is the same as or symmetrical to another view, the set may comprise only one of the two views. Also, bottom view of a product with a large size and weight is not required. Another example, one or more of the 7 views above are not required if the omitted views show very thin depths of the product. However, the reasons for omitted views must be indicated in the description.
  • For industrial designs of entire products or parts of products capable of being unfolded (expanded) into a planar form (for example, boxes, packaging articles, etc.), the views of the industrial design may be replaced by drawings/photos of the industrial design in its unfolded state;
  • More views for example, sectional views, enlarged views etc. may be required to clarify the design.
  • For a design that comprises many component parts, drawings/photos showing the parts may be provided for illustrating purpose, but drawings/photos of such parts will not constitute the protection scope.
  • For a design of product which is a component part of an integrated product, if the design is complex, a drawing/photo which shows the part within the integrated product to illustrate where it is installed and used may be required.
  • Drawings/photos must depict the industrial design in the same selected state of use. Drawings/photos depicting different states may be provided to clarify the nature of the industrial design. Where the industrial design of a non-physical product changes shape or moves, such an effect may be represented in a sequence of images, each image depicting a successive state in the transformation process.

Product definition

An industrial design means the external appearance of a product or part thereof in physical or non-physical form, expressed by shapes, lines, colors or a combination thereof and visible during the use of the product.

Product is understood as:

  • A physical product means an object existing in tangible material form, such as an article, tool, device, or equipment, manufactured by industrial or handicraft methods, having a definite structure and function;
  • A non-physical product means an object not existing in tangible material form, created through the projection or display of a design onto a surface or into an environment (including air), and having an actual function for operation, interaction, or the performance of a specific task. Examples are: graphic user interface (GUI), typefaces, and icons;
  • A part of a product means a part of the product for which the applicant seeks protection, including separable and inseparable parts.

From the definition, partial designs are patentable as industrial design in Vietnam.

The products of the same type and of different types

Products of the same type are products having identical or similar intended uses or functions. A product assembled from multiple components and the components used to assemble such a product are considered products of different types.

Appearance-forming feature and essential appearance-forming feature

Appearance-forming features are elements presented in the form of lines, shapes, colours, position or size correlation, or dimensional relationships of the claimed portion within the overall product; or the shape, arrangement layout, proportional relationships, display sequence, and visual effects of graphic elements on a non-physical product, which, in combination with other features, form the industrial design.

Essential appearance-forming features (characteristic features) are the features that are noticeable/memorable, necessary and sufficient to identify the nature of an industrial design and distinguish it from another one used for the products of the same type.

The following elements shall not be considered as characteristic features of an industrial design:

  • Shapes and lines dictated by the technical functions of the product (for example: the flat shape of data-recording disks is dictated by the relative motion between disks and reading heads, etc.);
  • Elements whose presence in the combination of features gives no aesthetic impression (impression of the shape of the product remains unchanged with or without those elements; for example: if a change in a familiar shape or line is not impressive enough to be noticed, therefore, the changed shape or line will be taken as the old one);
  • Materials used for manufacture of the product;
  • Information content displayed within a non-physical product (such as text, data, etc.); signs attached, affixed, etc., to a product solely for providing information or instructions regarding the origin, characteristics, structure, functions, uses, etc., of such product; for example, information on product labels (such as manufacturer, trade indications, origin, barcodes, etc.), trademarks, geographical indications, etc.;
  • Size of the product, except for change of size of patterns of a fabric sample or similar materials;
  • Features not visible during use of the product. For an industrial design of an independently registered separable component, the determination of non-visible features must be conducted based on the assembled product incorporating such a component;
  • Other elements failing to satisfy the requirements on characteristic features.

Colour per see is not regarded as a characteristic feature. However, for some specific products that their decoration of surface is important, such as labels, packaging, bowl, dish, etc., colours in a certain decoration composition that creates distinct aesthetic impression may be considered as a characteristic feature of the design.

Assessment of degree of difference of an industrial design

Two industrial designs are considered identical when they are used for products of the same type and have the same essential and non-essential appearance-forming features.

Two industrial designs are considered insignificantly different when they are used for the products of the same type and have the same essential appearance-forming features.

Two industrial designs are considered similar when they are used for products of the same type and have at least one essential appearance-forming feature identical to or insignificantly different from each other.

Two industrial designs are considered significantly different from each other when they are used for products of different types or used for the products of the same type but have at least one distinguishable essential appearance-forming feature.

Procedures

Industrial design applications will be formality examined, published, and substantively examined.

  • Formality examination: 01 month from the date on which IP Vietnam received the application in due form.
    • if the formality examination results are positive, the application will be published.
    • if the formality examination results are negative, IP Vietnam will issue a formality Office Action. The applicant can file response/amendments within 02 months from the date of the Office Action. If the applicant’s response is proper, the application will be published. If the applicant’s response is improper, a Decision on refusal of grant of patent will be issued.
  • Publication: an application passing the formality examination will be published in the Industrial Property Gazette within 01 month from the date on which the application is considered valid after formality examination.
    • deferment of publication: possible up to 07 months from the filing date, upon request.
  • Substantive examination: 05 months from the publication date.
    • if the substantive examination results are negative, IP Vietnam will issue a substantive Office Action. The applicant can file response/amendments within 02 months from the date of Office Action. IP Vietnam will issue a Notice of Allowance (if the applicant’s response is proper) or a Decision on refusal to grant a patent (if the applicant’s response is improper).
  • Grant: if the substantive examination results are positive, IP Vietnam will issue a Notice of Allowance. The applicant can pay the grant fees within 02 months from the date of the Notice. IP Vietnam will grant a patent within 01 month from the date of payment of required fees.
  • Overall turnaround from filing till grant: 10-18 months.

Amendment of pending application

A voluntary amendment can be filed any time during the prosecution of an application but must be filed before issuance of a Decision on grant (grant date) or Decision on refusal to grant design patent.

Amendments must not go beyond the content disclosed in the original drawings/photos and design description and must not change the nature of the subject matter stated in the application. Explanation for the amendments is required.

It is possible to amend the drawings/photos and design description after issuance of Notice of Allowance, however, the application is subject to re-examination.

Addition of embodiment(s) is possible.

Recordal of assignment, license, and change of name/address of applicant for pending application

Request for recordal of assignment or request for recordal of change of name/address of applicant of pending application can be filed any time during the prosecution of an application but must be filed before issuance of a Decision on grant (grant date) or Decision on refusal to grant design patent.

Licensing a pending application is impossible in Vietnam.

Merger or acquisition is recorded under the form of change of name and/or address of the applicant.

Divisional application

One or more divisional application(s) can be filed any time during prosecution of an application but must be filed before issuance of a Decision on grant (grant date) or Decision on refusal to grant design patent.

Appeal

It is possible to appeal against IP Vietnam’s decisions or notifications during any prosecution stage of application including filing, formality examination or substantive examination stage. Decisions or notifications that can be appealed are for example, Notification of Refusal to receiving application, Notification of acceptance or rejection of the request for amendment, assignment, Decision of refusal to grant, etc.

It is not possible to appeal IP Vietnam’s notifications that are aimed at providing information and require completion of the application, for example, Notifications of Examination Results, Notifications of Defects and Requests for Amendment/Supplementation of Documents, Notifications of Intention to Refuse Application.

First-instance appeal will be submitted to General Director of IP Vietnam. Deadline for first-instance appeal is 90 days from the date the appellant receives or becomes aware of IP Vietnam’s Decision or Notification.

Second-instance appeal will be submitted to the Minister of the Ministry of Science and Technology (MoST).Deadline for filing the second appeal is 30 days from the expiry date of the term for settlement of the first-instance appeal if by that date the first-instance appeal is not resolved, or from the date the appellant receives or becomes aware of the first Appeal Settlement Decision.

Amendment is impossible during the appeal procedure.

During appeal settlement, IP Vietnam or MoST can seek the opinions of independent advisory experts and advisory councils. IP Vietnam or MoST can organize direct discussion among the relevant parties with attendance of independent advisory experts and advisory councils if necessary.

Opposition and Third Party Opinion

While opposition and third party opinion are of the same nature and grounds, allowing a third party to submit its opinion on whether to grant a design application, the two procedures are different:

  • In opposition, a third party must submit its opinion within 03 months from the publication date of a design application. There are specific procedures and timelines for IP Vietnam to handle the opposition. IP Vietnam may organize a direct discussion between the two parties if necessary, and IP Vietnam must notify the third party of the substantive examination results.
  • In a third party opinion procedure, a third party can submit its opinion at any time before issuance of a Decision on grant or a Decision on refusal to grant a patent. IP Vietnam is not obligated to exchange correspondence between the parties. Opinion and documents submitted by the third party to IP Vietnam serve as reference materials during IP Vietnam’s examination process. In practice, the third party may discuss the case with the examiner to learn the examiner’s view on the issue and the examination results.

Double patenting

Double-patenting issue is provided under the “first-to-file” principle of the IP Law. In particular, if various applications have been filed for identical or insignificantly different industrial designs of the products of the same type, only one design patent will be granted. The design patent will be granted for the application with the earliest priority date or earliest filing date (if the application does not have the right of priority).

  • If the identical or insignificantly different industrial designs of products of the same type have the same filing date or same priority date, industrial design patent may be granted to the industrial design in one application only, as agreed upon by all applicants. If the applicants fail to reach an agreement, all applications shall be rejected.
  • The principle is also applied for cases in which a design of a component part of an integrated product if the integrated product containing such identical or insignificantly different part.

Provisional right upon the publication of an application

Before a design patent is granted, the intellectual property rights (IPR) owner has provisional right to the industrial design. Specifically, the IPR owner can send a warning letter informing the filing date and publication date in the Industrial Property Gazette and ask non-authorized user to terminate the use of the industrial design. If the user continues using such industrial design, then as soon as a design patent for industrial design is granted, the design patent owner shall have the right to request the user to pay compensation equivalent to the price for licensing of such industrial design within the corresponding scope and duration of use.

Renewal

Renewal fee is payable for granted industrial design patents within 06 months before ending the protection terms in order to renew the design patents.

The due date for payment of the first renewal fee is 5 years from the filing date and the second renewal fee is 10 years from the filing date. Failure to pay the renewal fee will result in a design patent being terminated.

Six-month grace period is available with a surcharge of 10% government renewal fee for each late month. Government renewal fee calculated each protection term based on number of embodiments.

A Power of Attorney (POA) is required for renewal payment. If there are more than one design patent owner, one POA from one of the design patent owners is sufficient.

Renewal of design patent for only one or some of the embodiments among all embodiments in a design patent is possible, provided that there must be at least the basis embodiment (the first embodiment listed in the design patent) is included in the renewal.

Original industrial design patent is not required for payment of renewal fee. The original design patent is required only in case the industrial design patent owner wants to record IP Vietnam’s renewal decision in the design patent (last page of the design patent). In addition, if the design patent owner has not recorded the renewal decision in the design patent when paying renewal fee and then later, if the design patent owner wants to record the renewal decision in the design patent, the design patent owner can request amendment of design patent to record the renewal decision in the design patent.

Renewal for both two five-year terms at the same time is impossible.

Recordal of assignment, licensing, and change of name/address of design patent owner

An assignment is required to be recorded at IP Vietnam. There is no deadline for requesting to record the assignment.

A license is not required to record at the Vietnamese competent authority. A license contract is valid as agreed by the parties. However, such contract is only legally effective to a third party if it is registered with the Vietnamese competent authority.

Change of name/address of patent owner can be recorded at IP Vietnam. There is no deadline for requesting to record the change. Merger or acquisition is recorded under the form of change of name and/or address of the patent owner.

Original patent is required for recordal of name/address change and assignment while it is not required for license recordal.

Amendment of design patent

It is only possible to narrow the scope of protection of a design patent, specifically, by deleting one or more embodiments or deleting one or more products in the set of products.

Correction/rectification of errors in a design patent

A design patent owner can request IP Vietnam to correct/rectify errors in the design patent. The design patent owner must pay a required fee for the rectification if the error is due to its fault. If the error is caused by IP Vietnam, the design patent owner is not required to pay the fee.

Termination and Invalidation

Termination:

A design patent can be terminated on the following grounds:

  • Design patent owner has not paid the renewal fees;
  • Design patent owner has declared its relinquishment of the rights conferred by the design patent;
  • Design patent owner no longer exists.

Time limit for requesting termination: the entire design patent term.

Invalidation:

A design patent can be invalidated entirely on the following ground:

  • The designer(s) is/are not a human.

A design patent can be invalidated entirely or invalidated partially if the entire patent or certain parts of the patent do not meet the requirements, on the following grounds:

  • The applicant was neither entitled to file the application nor assigned such right;
  • The industrial design in the design patent did not meet the patentability requirements or is contrary to the social ethics and public order and prejudicial to defence and security at the time of grant;
  • Amendment, addition of application containing the subject-matter extends beyond the scope of the subject-matter disclosed in the original application, or changes the nature of the subject-matter disclosed in the original application.
  • The industrial design did not meet the first-to-file principle.

Amendment during invalidation: there is no specific regulations and there is no prohibition of amendment during nullity procedure.

Appeal on post grant

Like pending applications, it is possible to appeal against IP Vietnam’s decisions or notifications during the post-grant stage. Decisions or notifications that can be appealed include, for example, notifications or decisions of refusal or acceptance of annuity/renewal, amendment of patent, termination, or invalidation of patent.

Also, it is not possible to appeal IP Vietnam’s notifications that are aimed at providing information and require completion of the application, for example, notifications of examination results, notifications of defects and requests for amendment/supplementation of documents, notifications of intention to refuse request.

The appeal settlement is the same as that for pending applications as noted above.

Ready to take the next step?

Get a free initial consultation

Our attorneys are ready to advise you on protecting your intellectual property across Southeast Asia. We typically respond within one business day.